Rethinking ACL Injuries: What 30+ Years of Research Tell Us About Non-Surgical Recovery

Dr. Molly Pierson, PT, DPT • April 3, 2026

Knee PT in Holly Springs

For decades, an ACL tear has often been viewed as a one-way path to surgery, especially for athletes. But, emerging long-term research is challenging that assumption. A landmark 2024 study by Hellberg and colleagues offers a rare and valuable perspective. What actually happens to patients more than 30 years after a nonoperative ACL injury? The results may reshape how we think about treatment and reinforce the critical role of physical therapy. The study followed patients who initially treated their ACL injuries without surgery and checked in over three decades later.


 The results showed the following:

  • 65% of patients reported good or excellent knee function decades after injury 
  • Activity levels decreased over time, with an average drop in sports participation 
  • 75% showed radiographic signs of osteoarthritis (OA), but only 38% had symptomatic OA 
  • About 71% never required ACL reconstruction later in life 


In simple terms: many people functioned well long-term,even without surgery. While there is a time and place for surgery, this shows that it is not the only route to recovery. The main focus to take away from this study is functional recovery vs imaging. 

One of the most important insights from this study is the disconnect between what shows up on imaging and how patients actually feel. While a large portion of participants had signs of osteoarthritis on X-rays, far fewer experienced symptoms that affected daily life. This highlights a key concept in physical therapy: structural changes don’t always equal pain or disability. For clinicians and patients alike, this reinforces the importance of focusing on function, strength, and quality of movement, not just what an image shows.

So how did these patients maintain function for decades? The study points to two major factors, which include early physical therapy and activity modification.  Patients were guided to strengthen the knee and avoid high-risk movements like pivoting and cutting. Over time, many adapted their activity levels—but maintained independence and quality of life. 


This aligns closely with modern rehab principles:

  • Build strong quadriceps and hamstrings
  • Improve neuromuscular control and stability
  • Gradually return to activity based on function—not timelines


Surgery Isn’t Always the First Answer. This research doesn’t suggest that surgery is unnecessary, but it does challenge the idea that it’s always required.Instead, it supports a “rehab-first” approach, especially for individuals who have lower to moderate activity levels, and can achieve stability through strength and control. The other important factor is willingness to modify high-risk activities. Only about 29% of patients eventually needed reconstuction due to instability if they could address those 3 main factors.


What Does This Means for Patients Today?

If you’ve recently torn your ACL, this study offers an important perspective about more conservative treatments. This could mean that you many not need surgery immediately and long-term function is possible with the right rehab plan. Physical therapy is not just a supplement. It can be the foundation of recovery however, it’s also important to recognize that outcomes vary. Athletes in high-demand sports or those with persistent instability may still benefit from surgical reconstruction.The 30+ year findings from Hellberg et al. remind us that recovery from an ACL injury is not just about fixing a ligament, it’s about building a resilient, functional knee for life (2024).Whether you choose surgery or not, physical therapy remains the cornerstone of long-term success.


References


Hellberg, C., Kostogiannis, I., Stylianides, A., & Neuman, P. (2024). Outcomes >30 Years After Initial Nonoperative Treatment of Anterior Cruciate Ligament Injuries.
The American journal of sports medicine, 52(2), 320–329. https://doi.org/10.1177/03635465231214423


Learn More About Knee Pain
By Dr. Christine Melchor, PT, DPT June 28, 2026
Urinary Leakage Pelvic Floor PT - Holly Springs, NC
By Dr. Nicole Perna, PT, DPT June 1, 2026
Virtual Pelvic Floor Physical Therapy North Carolina
By Dr. Rebecca Acevedo, PT, DPT June 1, 2026
You discovered pickleball. Maybe a neighbor dragged you out, or you spotted a court on your morning walk and got curious. Either way, you're hooked — and you're not alone. Pickleball is now the fastest-growing sport in the U.S., and for good reason. It's social, competitive, and genuinely fun. But here's the thing nobody warns you about when you pick up that paddle: your body is working harder than it looks. We're seeing more pickleball players walk through our doors than ever before, and the injuries range from minor annoyances to the kind that sideline you for months. The good news? Most of them are preventable. Let's talk about what's happening out there on the court and what you can actually do about it. The Pickleball Body Check: What's Really Being Asked of You Pickleball might look like a slower, smaller version of tennis, but don't let the compact court fool you. The sport demands rapid direction changes, explosive lateral shuffles, overhead swings, and a whole lot of forward lunging toward the kitchen line. That combination puts serious stress on your knees, shoulders, ankles, and lower back — often in the same rally. Emergency department visits for pickleball injuries jumped from roughly 1,300 in 2014 to over 24,000 in 2023. And the population playing? Largely adults over 50, a group that's more susceptible to the wear-and-tear that accumulates quietly before something finally gives. The Most Common Injuries We See Knee pain tops the list, accounting for nearly 30% of pickleball injuries. The repeated stop-and-start movements, combined with lunging, put a heavy load on the knee joint and surrounding tendons. Patellar tendinopathy (think: achy pain just below the kneecap) is extremely common, especially in players who ramped up their game quickly. Shoulder issues come in close behind. That dinking motion looks harmless until you've done it 400 times in a week. Rotator cuff strains and biceps tendon irritation show up regularly in players who skip a warm-up or swing with poor mechanics. Ankle sprains are often the result of quick lateral moves on uneven outdoor courts, or simply misjudging a step near the baseline. "Pickleball elbow" — yes, it's a thing — is essentially the same lateral epicondylitis (tennis elbow) most people know, caused by repetitive gripping and wrist extension during groundstrokes and volleys. Falls deserve their own mention. They account for nearly 63% of all pickleball-related emergency visits. Moving backward and lunging sideways are the top culprits. If your balance or reaction time isn't where it used to be, that's something a physical therapist can directly address. What Physical Therapy Actually Does for Pickleball Players Here's the part that surprises a lot of people: physical therapy isn't just for after you get hurt. It's one of the best tools for keeping you on the court in the first place. When you're already injured , a PT evaluates not just the painful spot but everything connected to it. A knee problem often traces back to hip weakness or poor ankle mobility. Treating only where it hurts misses the bigger picture. Your therapist will use hands-on techniques — joint mobilization, soft tissue work, dry needling — alongside a targeted exercise program to get you back to full function, not just "good enough." When you want to stay healthy , a PT can spot movement problems before they become injuries. We call these "movement screens," and they're eye-opening. A lot of players have no idea they have limited hip rotation or weak glutes until we actually test for them. 4 Things You Can Start Doing This Week You don't have to wait for an injury to make changes. These are the things we recommend to every pickleball player, beginner or seasoned: 1. Warm up like you mean it. A five-minute walk from the parking lot doesn't count. Spend 10 minutes doing leg swings, hip circles, light lateral shuffles, and arm circles before you pick up a paddle. Your joints need to be warm before they're loaded. 2. Build your hip and glute strength. Weak hips are behind a surprising number of knee and lower back complaints. Side-lying clamshells, single-leg deadlifts, and lateral band walks aren't glamorous, but they work. Three sets, two to three times a week off the court. 3. Work on your balance. Stand on one foot for 30 seconds. Easy? Try it with your eyes closed. Balance training directly reduces your fall risk on the court and improves your footwork in the process. It takes five minutes and you can do it while brushing your teeth. 4. Don't ignore the small stuff. That nagging achiness in your elbow or the twinge in your shoulder after a session? That's your body sending an early signal. Get it looked at before it becomes a full-on problem. Early intervention almost always means a shorter recovery. A Word About Playing Through Pain We get it. You've got court time reserved, your regular group is waiting, and it's "probably nothing." But playing through pain — especially joint pain — often turns a two-week recovery into a two-month one. If something hurts during play and doesn't settle down within 48 hours of modified activities, it's worth a conversation with a physical therapist. Most issues caught early can be addressed without putting you on the shelf. The Bottom Line Pickleball is a sport you can genuinely play for decades — if you take care of the machine that plays it. The players we see staying on the court well into their 60s and 70s aren't necessarily the most talented. They're the ones who warm up consistently, do their strength work, and don't wait until they're limping to ask for help. If you've been dealing with something that's nagging at you, or you just want to move better on the court, we'd love to see you. A physical therapy evaluation is a great starting point!
By Dr. Molly Pierson, PT, DPT May 4, 2026
Physical Therapy for Chronic Pain in Holly Springs, NC
By Evolve Physical Therapy May 4, 2026
Pelvic Floor Physical Therapy in Holly Springs, NC
By Dr. Rebecca Acevedo, PT, DPT April 16, 2026
Postpartum Pelvic Floor Specialists - Holly Springs, NC
By Dr. Nicole Perna, PT, DPT April 16, 2026
Hip Pain Physical Therapy Experts - Holly Springs, NC
By Dr. Molly Pierson, PT, DPT April 16, 2026
Pelvic Floor Physical Therapy for Pelvic Pain - Holly Springs, NC
By Dr. Molly Pierson, PT, DPT March 8, 2026
Orthopedic Physical Therapy, Holly Springs, NC
By Dr. Nicole Perna, PT, DPT March 7, 2026
Dry Needling in Holly Springs, NC